Royal Dutch Shell Plc  .com Rotating Header Image

Don’t forget the other recent Shell management humanitarian gesture: “the largest securities fraud settlement ever reached in Europe”


 Dutch Appeals Court Orders Royal Dutch Shell to Begin Paying $450 Million Settlement to Pan-European/Global Investor Group AMSTERDAM, THE NETHERLANDS (May 29, 2009) – Officially approving the largest securities fraud settlement ever reached in Europe, a Dutch appeals court has ordered Royal Dutch Shell plc. to begin payment of $450 million to a foundation representing a group of institutional investors from seventeen European countries, plus Canada and Australia. 
The binding declaration was issued by the Amsterdam Court of Appeals, which in April 2007 agreed to serve as a forum for the investor group and Shell to work together in reaching a settlement of securities fraud claims stemming from the oil giant’s inflation of its proven oil and gas reserves during the years 1997-2003. 

The agreement – which has grown to include more than 150 public pension funds in Europe, North American and Australia- is a particular milestone for European investors, given that European courts lack a class action mechanism for pursuing securities fraud claims. Under a relatively new statute never previously applied to a securities case, Dutch law allowed the Amsterdam appellate court to accept a collective resolution as long as both sides agreed, even in absence of a civil lawsuit.

The $450 million settlement covers all non-U.S. purchasers of Shell stock obtained on European securities exchanges – principally London and Amsterdam – during the period of Shell’s allegedly illegal energy reserve accounting. The pension funds leading the settlement represent millions of public and trade-based employees across Western Europe, including: The Netherlands; United Kingdom, Scotland, Ireland, Germany, Sweden, Luxembourg, France, Denmark, Austria, Belgium, Finland, Italy, Liechtenstein, Spain, Switzerland and Norway.

Under the settlement, Shell is making its payment to a foundation specifically created to petition the Court of Appeals on behalf of the investor group. Leading U.S. securities and corporate governance law firm Grant & Eisenhofer represents both the special purpose foundation and the pension funds, which held in excess of one billion shares of Shell during the years the company exaggerated its reserves.

As a result of the extended inflation of its energy reserves, Shell was forced to issue multiple large financial restatements beginning in 2004. Estimates are that over the six-year period covered by the case, Shell overstated more than $100 billion of future cash flows, based on billions of barrels of oil that were not actually held in its reserves.

“We are pleased that the Amsterdam Court of Appeals has issued its final approval on this historic settlement, which represents a watershed outcome for European and other non-US investors in gaining substantial, collective recovery in one of the most high-profile securities cases in recent years,” saidJay Eisenhofer, co-managing partner of Grant & Eisenhofer.  
“It is important that investors have a proper mechanism and forum for pursuing securities claims in European courts – the Amsterdam Court of Appeals has done a tremendous service for advancing shareholder rights in its handling of the Shell case,” he added. “This was a uniquely European resolution in the context of a securities fraud, but one that can present huge implications in other disputes going forward.”

Note: Grant & Eisenhofer P.A. represents institutional investors and shareholders internationally in securities class actions, corporate governance actions and derivative litigation. The firm has recovered more than $12 billion for investors in the last five years. G&E has also been selected among The National Law Journal‘s “Plaintiffs’ Hot List” for the past four years, and is a member of its Hall of Fame. Risk Metrics named Grant & Eisenhofer the Number 1 law firm in average shareholder recoveries in securities class actions in 2007 and 2008. For more information, visit


News Contact: Allan Ripp
Email: [email protected]
Phone: 212-262-7477

SOURCE ARTICLE headline by John Donovan and its also non-profit sister websites,,,,, and are all owned by John Donovan. There is also a Wikipedia article.

0 Comments on “Don’t forget the other recent Shell management humanitarian gesture: “the largest securities fraud settlement ever reached in Europe””

Leave a Comment

%d bloggers like this: