Royal Dutch Shell Plc  .com Rotating Header Image

Windfall tax on Energy Giants Shell and BP?

The Telegraph

Energy bosses are provoking Sunak into another ruinous tax raid

BP chief executive may live to regret calling his company a ‘cash machine’: Shell unveiled a quadrupling of profits and a bumper payout for shareholders. Chief Ben van Beurden sounded cock-a-hoop. It had been “a momentous year”, he declared.

You’ve got to hand it to the bosses of Britain’s energy giants. The response of the industry’s top figures to growing calls from the Labour Party, trade unions, and eco-activists for a windfall tax has been so risible that a Conservative Government is now said to be warming to the idea, having repeatedly ruled it out.

If ministers change their minds and conduct a profit raid on BP and Shell to help alleviate the cost of living crisis – and reports suggest this is now under serious consideration – then the two companies will be remembered for scoring one of the greatest own goals in modern corporate history.

It’s a u-turn that the Government has been desperately trying to avoid. The Prime Minister warned only last week that a tax grab could put the UK’s future energy security at risk. And on Thursday, Boris Johnson again signalled his opposition to the move, reiterating his belief, in an interview with LBC radio, that it would “deter investment”.

Kwasi Kwarteng even went to the trouble of handing the oil producers a gift-wrapped opportunity to avoid the Treasury’s grasp. If they were able to provide a clear plan to spend their profits to accelerate domestic energy production and “bring down consumer bills in the long term” then BP, Shell, and other North Sea players could count on “the UK Government’s ongoing support”, the Business Secretary said. In other words, they would be spared from a regressive windfall tax.

That was a mere 10 days ago. And now? Officials are said to be so incensed by the behaviour of the industry’s leading names at a time when horror stories of one pensioner riding the bus to keep warm and another praying to stay in hospital rather than go home to a cold house dominate the headlines, that a windfall tax is on the table.

The turning point was clearly BP boss Bernard Looney’s admission, on the back of the company’s biggest quarterly profits in a decade, that a tax wouldn’t alter BP’s investment plans.

The roots of the current backlash can be traced back to last November and Looney’s boast that BP was “a cash machine” at a time of high oil and gas prices but growing financial difficulty for millions of families.

Shell has proven no more politically adept. In February, on the very same day that households up and down the country discovered that their energy bills were heading for a 50pc, and the Bank of England was warning of record squeeze on earnings, Shell unveiled a quadrupling of profits and a bumper payout for shareholders. Chief Ben van Beurden sounded cock-a-hoop. It had been “a momentous year”, he declared.

Nor did it help that Kwarteng’s olive branch was met with unconvincing attempts to repackage existing investment projects as new plans that would strengthen the UK’s attempts to become less exposed to the oscillations of global oil and gas markets. BP’s decision to lavish billions of pounds on investors in the form of dividends and buybacks was another massive blunder.


This website and sisters,,,, and, are owned by John Donovan. There is also a Wikipedia segment.

Comments are closed.

Comment Rules

  • Please show respect to the opinions of others no matter how seemingly far-fetched.
  • Abusive, foul language, and/or divisive comments may be deleted without notice.
  • Each blog member is allowed limited comments, as displayed above the comment box.
  • Comments must be limited to the number of words displayed above the comment box.
  • Please limit one comment after any comment posted per post.