Shell Loses Landmark Case Because Apparently, Destroying Nigerian Communities for Profit Isn’t Enough—They Tried to Weasel Out of Responsibility Too

Shell Loses Landmark Case Because Apparently, Destroying Nigerian Communities for Profit Isn’t Enough—They Tried to Weasel Out of Responsibility Too

Posted by John Donovan: 12 Oct 2024

In a stunning twist that absolutely no one saw coming, oil behemoth Shell, the model of corporate ethics (wink), has lost yet another court battle. This time, the UK Court of Appeal has handed down a major ruling in favor of two Nigerian communities, the Bille and Ogale, whose land, water, and livelihoods have been systematically obliterated by oil pollution—allegedly caused by none other than Shell’s Nigerian subsidiary, SPDC.

The Bille and Ogale communities have been living in an environmental nightmare for years, courtesy of around 100 oil spills from Shell’s crumbling infrastructure. These spills have rendered their land uninhabitable, poisoned their water, and left them unable to farm or fish. But Shell—because why accept responsibility when you can stall, deflect, and confuse—managed to string this case out for ten years, while thousands of people suffered, and many even died waiting for justice.

Let’s rewind to March 2024, when the High Court bent over backwards to help Shell avoid accountability by ruling that the Nigerian communities needed to prove which specific oil spill caused exactly what damage, from the very beginning of the case—before they’d even had a chance to get their hands on the key evidence locked up in Shell’s vaults. Lawyers for Shell’s victims called this an “impossibly high burden” for claimants to meet, which, let’s face it, was exactly the point.

Because, you know, it’s totally reasonable to expect people who’ve watched their entire environment slowly turn into a toxic wasteland to pinpoint, with precision, which of 100 oil spills destroyed their farmland or poisoned their drinking water. Shell and their lawyers were essentially saying, “Yeah, we may have polluted your land for decades, but can you really prove it was us? And every single time?” Classic.

But in an unexpected display of logic and justice, the Court of Appeal finally stepped in, overturning the ludicrous High Court ruling. This means that the case will now actually move forward to trial—finally giving the communities a shot at holding Shell accountable. It only took a decade and two trips to the UK’s highest courts! Justice sure moves quickly when you’re up against a corporate giant with a legal team bigger than most governments.

Dan Leader of Leigh Day, the legal team representing the Bille and Ogale communities, wasn’t mincing words when he said, “It has been ten years since these two Nigerian communities first brought their claims in the UK courts, and many of our clients have died while awaiting justice.”

Ten years, folks. Ten years of Shell dragging this out, tying the case in legal knots, and hoping the clock would just run out on the people whose homes and futures it helped destroy. Remember, this is the same company that made €23 billion in profits over four decades in the region. But apparently, actually taking responsibility for the damage they’ve caused? That’s just asking too much.

This ruling marks a major shift for future environmental claims, sending a clear message that maybe—just maybe—you can’t spend decades polluting the world’s most vulnerable communities and get away with it by hiding behind technicalities. This “Global Claim” nonsense, which Shell tried to invoke to make the entire case impossible, was basically tossed out by the Court of Appeal. Now, claimants like the Bille and Ogale can finally bring complex environmental claims without being asked to pull off legal gymnastics before they’ve even seen the evidence.

So while Shell’s shareholders—like, say, BlackRock—continue raking in profits, it looks like the people of Bille and Ogale might just get a sliver of justice. The trial will now proceed, with Shell finally being forced to open its vault of documents that will likely tell the ugly story of just how badly they’ve damaged these communities.

Is this the beginning of the end for Shell’s relentless evasion of responsibility? Probably not. But for the people who’ve been fighting for a decade to be heard, it’s a step in the right direction.

This website and sisters royaldutchshellgroup.com, shellnazihistory.com, royaldutchshell.website, johndonovan.website, and shellnews.net, are owned by John Donovan. There is also a Wikipedia segment.