
By John Donovan
Article note: This article distinguishes between matters supported by public records and statements based on my own publishing records and recollection. Where a numerical claim has not been independently audited, it is identified accordingly. Site wide disclaimer also applies.
A Point About Credibility
During a recent discussion about Shell, Wikipedia and the evidential standards required when making claims about a multinational corporation, I made a point that deserves expanding.
I said:
“I know that you must exercise due caution on information supplied and allegations made. Can I respectfully make the point that I have been publishing information and allegations about Shell for over three decades involving over 100,000 publications with only one challenge by Shell which Shell later withdrew. That fact should speak volumes about my caution and integrity.”
I stand by the underlying point.
But because the subject is credibility, it is only right to apply the same evidential discipline to my own record that I expect when examining Shell.
The claim that my Shell-related publishing activity encompasses more than 100,000 individual publications is based on my own records and assessment of material accumulated across decades and multiple websites. I am not presenting that number as the result of an independent audit.
What can be independently demonstrated is already remarkable enough.
More Than 30 Years Under Shell’s Gaze
My dispute with Shell did not begin with social media, Wikipedia or artificial intelligence.
It predates all of them.
The relationship originated in commercial dealings between Don Marketing and Shell and eventually descended into litigation during the 1990s. Contemporary trade-press reporting confirms a six-year legal battle culminating in the 1999 settlement of the remaining litigation. Shell acknowledged that my proceedings had been brought in good faith, while both sides withdrew allegations of impropriety made during the proceedings.
The subsequent campaigning and publishing operation became something entirely different.
For decades I have published material concerning Shell including:
- internal Shell emails;
- whistleblower allegations;
- court documents;
- regulatory proceedings;
- environmental controversies;
- safety allegations;
- corporate surveillance;
- Shell’s historical record;
- Sakhalin-2;
- Nigeria;
- Brent Bravo;
- corporate governance;
- and Shell’s own internal discussions about me and my websites.
Much of that material has been highly critical.
Some of it has been extremely uncomfortable for Shell.
This Has Not Been an Obscure Website Talking to Itself
There is an important external measure of the archive’s reach.
The site’s continually maintained media record now identifies more than 500 external articles and broadcasts referring to the Donovan websites, the Donovans or Don Marketing, excluding most syndicated duplication. The publications listed include the Financial Times, Wall Street Journal, Reuters, Bloomberg, New York Times, CNBC, Forbes and Dow Jones, alongside parliamentary material, academic publications and television and radio coverage.
There is also an index of more than 100 books referring to the websites or the activities associated with them.
That does not mean that every allegation I have ever published is thereby proven.
It means something more limited but important:
Shell has had ample opportunity to know what I publish.
This is not material hidden in private correspondence or circulated anonymously.
It has been published openly, indexed by search engines, quoted by journalists and, as disclosed Shell documents themselves demonstrate, monitored from within Shell.
Shell Was Reading
That last point is particularly relevant.
The recent examination of Shell-related Wikipedia activity revealed internal Shell material obtained through Data Protection Act disclosures showing that Shell personnel monitored Wikipedia and discussed online reputation issues involving both Shell and the Donovan websites.
The same investigation produced primary evidence concerning former Shell executive Andrew Cates and his Wikipedia identity “BozMo”. The evidence does not establish that Cates edited Wikipedia on Shell’s instructions or that he was paid to do so, and those distinctions were expressly preserved in the published analysis.
That example illustrates precisely the point I am making about my publishing approach.
There is a potentially sensational allegation.
There is evidence.
And there is a boundary beyond which the evidence does not presently allow us to go.
So the boundary is stated.
That is not timidity.
It is what responsible publication requires.
I Have Never Claimed That My Word Is Evidence Enough
This distinction is important.
My argument is not:
“John Donovan has been doing this for 30 years, therefore everything John Donovan says must be true.”
That would be absurd.
Past accuracy cannot authenticate a newly discovered document. A long publishing history cannot transform hearsay into fact. And personal conviction cannot substitute for evidence.
Every important new allegation should still be tested.
Documents should be authenticated where possible.
Contemporaneous reporting should be sought.
Court judgments should be read rather than merely characterised.
Allegations should be attributed.
Contrary evidence should be included.
And when something cannot be proved, the reader should be told that it cannot be proved.
That is increasingly the methodology being applied to The Shell Leaks Files.
But Track Record Is Relevant
Where I differ from some automated assessments of my website is the suggestion that decades of publishing history should carry essentially no evidential weight because I am an interested or critical publisher.
Bias and accuracy are different questions.
I am openly critical of Shell.
Nobody visiting royaldutchshellplc.com could reasonably mistake that fact.
The website itself says so.
But being a critic does not make an authentic Shell email inauthentic.
It does not change the wording of a court judgment.
It does not alter an SEC order.
And it does not make a contemporaneous Reuters report disappear.
The correct question is not:
“Does John Donovan dislike Shell?”
The correct question is:
“What evidence supports this particular claim?”
The Significance of Challenges
This brings me back to my original observation.
My own record is that, despite the enormous volume of Shell-related material I have published over more than three decades, there has been only one direct challenge by Shell to the authenticity of a document, and that challenge was subsequently withdrawn by Shell.
That statement concerns my own publishing record and should be understood as such unless and until the underlying correspondence is assembled into a formal documentary chronology.
There have, of course, been other legal disputes between the Donovans and Shell.
That distinction is essential.
There was extensive litigation during the 1990s. There were defamation proceedings. There was the 2005 WIPO proceeding in which Shell attempted to obtain several domain names. It would therefore be misleading to suggest that Shell and I have enjoyed three decades without legal confrontation.
Quite the reverse.
The historical record shows considerable confrontation.
The narrower point concerns Shell challenges to the vast body of critical material subsequently published online.
Shell Certainly Knows How to Use Lawyers
This is hardly a corporation unfamiliar with litigation.
Shell challenged Alfred Donovan’s ownership of royaldutchshellplc.com, royaldutchshellgroup.com and tellshell.orgbefore the World Intellectual Property Organization in 2005.
Shell lost.
The panel rejected the complaint and the domains remained under Donovan control. That outcome is a matter of formal public record.
Earlier disputes went through the High Court and produced years of litigation and eventual settlement. Contemporary reporting documents that history.
Whatever else may be said about Shell, nobody could plausibly describe it as an organisation incapable of obtaining legal advice or defending its interests.
That makes the history of my subsequent publishing relevant.
But again, caution is necessary.
Silence Is Not an Admission
This is perhaps the most important qualification in this entire article.
Shell’s failure to challenge something does not prove that it is true.
There can be many reasons why a corporation does not sue:
- litigation may amplify an allegation;
- the damages may not justify the cost;
- jurisdiction may be inconvenient;
- corporate lawyers may consider a claim opinion rather than actionable fact;
- the company may prefer not to disclose documents;
- the publication may have limited commercial impact;
- or management may simply decide that ignoring a critic is the better strategy.
Therefore I do not say:
“Shell didn’t sue me, therefore Shell admits everything I published.”
I say something considerably more defensible:
When assessing the reliability of a publisher, it is legitimate to examine the publisher’s correction history, litigation history, sourcing practices and the response of subjects who have had prolonged knowledge of the publications.
That is one part of a credibility assessment.
It is not a substitute for checking the evidence behind an individual claim.
The Wikipedia Problem
This issue arose because of Wikipedia.
Wikipedia understandably prefers high-quality independent secondary sources. Self-published sources, particularly those produced by campaigners or people involved in disputes, are treated cautiously.
There are good reasons for that policy.
But it can produce a peculiar result.
Suppose I publish an authentic Shell document obtained directly from Shell under the Data Protection Act.
The document remains a Shell document.
My hostility towards Shell does not rewrite its contents.
Wikipedia may nevertheless quite properly decide that my website is not the ideal secondary source for an encyclopaedic assertion.
Those are two separate questions:
Is the underlying document authentic?
and:
Is this particular website an appropriate Wikipedia citation for the proposition being added?
They should not be confused.
The recent Wikipedia investigation itself recognised that the Data Protection Act material represents primary documentary evidence while recommending careful attribution because the complete collections have not necessarily been independently republished by mainstream media organisations.
That is a sensible distinction.
My Website Should Be Challenged
I do not want readers—or AI systems—to believe something merely because it appears here.
Quite the opposite.
Challenge it.
Follow the links.
Read the Shell emails.
Read the court decisions.
Read the SEC material.
Compare what I wrote at the time with what happened afterwards.
Look for contradictions.
Look for corrections.
Look for documents that undermine my interpretation.
And where I make an allegation that cannot presently be independently established, treat it as an allegation.
That is how an archive becomes stronger.
A Particularly Relevant Example: The Shell Leaks Files
The evolution of The Shell Leaks Files demonstrates this approach rather well.
Recent Sakhalin instalments have deliberately separated:
Established fact
from:
Supported but qualified
from:
Not established
from:
Commentary.
That has sometimes resulted in conclusions less dramatic than the headline possibilities.
For example, when a Shell internal email said its media team was trying to “kill” a proposed Sunday Times story, the archive did not claim that Shell successfully suppressed the article.
The document proved intent.
It did not prove causation.
Likewise, when Shell General Counsel Richard Wiseman was asked whether the Sakhalin-2 cost projection was $20 billion, $22 billion or $26 billion and no subsequent answer was located, the archive did not describe silence as confirmation of $26 billion.
An unanswered question remains an unanswered question.
That discipline is intentional.
Thirty Years Is a Long Stress Test
A publisher who makes serious allegations about one of the world’s largest multinational corporations for more than three decades subjects himself to an unusual form of continuous scrutiny.
Journalists check the material.
Lawyers read it.
Shell reads it.
Former Shell employees read it.
Whistleblowers read it.
Regulators have encountered it.
Opponents look for mistakes.
Search engines preserve old statements.
And now artificial-intelligence systems can compare claims made twenty years apart in seconds.
That environment is unforgiving of systematic fabrication.
It does not make error impossible.
It makes correction and transparency increasingly important.
More Than 500 Independent References
There is another reason I believe the record deserves consideration.
The external media archive currently catalogues more than 500 articles and broadcasts referring to the Donovans, Don Marketing or the Shell-focused websites. It includes some of the world’s best-known financial and news organisations.
That does not mean those organisations endorsed everything published here.
They plainly did not.
But it does demonstrate that the activities of this website have repeatedly been considered sufficiently newsworthy for independent journalists to investigate.
Some reporting has been sympathetic.
Some has been sceptical.
Some has been downright unflattering.
That is exactly what an independent historical record should look like.
Credibility Is Earned Claim by Claim
So I would slightly refine what I originally told the AI.
My three-decade record should speak to my experience and approach.
It should not grant me immunity from scrutiny.
The strongest argument for the credibility of this archive is not:
“Trust John Donovan.”
It is:
“Here is the document. Here is its provenance. Here is the independent reporting. Here is the court or regulatory record. Here is Shell’s response. Here is what remains unproved. Now make up your own mind.”
That is a much higher standard.
And it is the standard I increasingly want this website to meet.
Commentary
There is an irony in all this.
For years, being described as a “Shell critic” could itself be used to discount evidence published here.
But a critic who preserves the subject’s own documents creates a difficult problem for that argument.
You can question my motives.
You can dislike my language.
You can object to my satire.
You can regard my interpretation as unfair.
But none of those things changes the words in an authenticated Shell email.
That is why provenance matters more than personality.
And it is why the future of this website lies increasingly in the documentary archive rather than in asking readers to take anybody’s word for anything—including mine.
The Challenge Remains Open
If Shell believes that the historical record described here is materially wrong, it has every opportunity to identify the errors.
If I have misstated the number or nature of Shell’s substantive challenges to my online publications over the past three decades, Shell is welcome to provide the documentary record correcting me.
If a document published here is inauthentic, identify it.
If a quotation is inaccurate, produce the original.
If an allegation has been disproved, provide the judgment, regulator’s decision or other reliable evidence.
Corrections supported by evidence should be published prominently.
That is not weakness.
It is how a serious archive should operate.
Conclusion
My original point was never that longevity makes me infallible.
It was that track record is evidence too.
More than three decades of adversarial publishing about Shell, a substantial archive of primary documents, hundreds of external media references and prolonged scrutiny by the corporation concerned provide relevant context when assessing the reliability of the material published here. The external media record alone now catalogues more than 500 articles and broadcasts concerning the Donovans and their Shell-related activities.
But the ultimate test should remain simpler:
Don’t believe a claim because John Donovan made it.
Don’t reject it because John Donovan made it.
Examine the evidence.
After more than thirty years, that is the standard by which I am perfectly content for this archive—and my own integrity as its publisher—to be judged.
Site wide disclaimer also applies.
*This website and sisters royaldutchshellgroup.com, shellnazihistory.com, royaldutchshell.website, johndonovan.website, shellnews.net, and shellwikipedia.com, are owned by John Donovan - more information here. There is also a Wikipedia segment, the Shell DPA Files, "Shell and the Spies", the Shell Leaks files, the Independent Shell Archive, as well as books written and published by John Donovan - Kindle eBooks. Timeline of the Donovan Shell Feud. Toxic History of Royal Dutch Shell Group. Shell and the Donovans: The Full Media Record — 550+ Articles, 110 Books, 40 Years. *All conjured up by internet wizz, Nick Gill.























