The Shell Leaks Files
SLF-2007-018
The Sakhalin Papers VIII: The Memo, The Whistleblower And The Parliamentary Record
Archive Reference: SLF-2007-018
Collection: The Sakhalin Papers
Evidence Standard: Authenticated or corporately acknowledged Shell communications, contemporaneous reporting, parliamentary evidence and official project records.
Introduction
In June 2007, a leaked memo from Sakhalin Energy’s deputy chief executive, David Greer, landed in the Financial Times. Its martial language, borrowed from General George S. Patton, was striking. So was Shell’s confirmation that the email was genuine. The following year, a quite separate set of whistleblower allegations concerning Sakhalin II was cited in evidence submitted by WWF to a House of Commons committee.
“Pipeliners All!”
Sakhalin II was not a project short of pressure. It was a vast oil-and-gas development in Russia’s far east, involving offshore platforms, pipelines across the island, an LNG plant and export facilities. Costs had risen sharply, environmental concerns were public and, after the 2006 Gazprom agreement, Shell and its Japanese partners had accepted a dramatic reduction in their ownership interests.
Against that backdrop, David Greer, then deputy chief executive of Sakhalin Energy Investment Company (SEIC) and project director, sent an email to staff dated 18 April 2007. It was addressed to “Pipeliners All!” and urged employees to meet the task ahead. The email became public after being supplied to the Financial Times.
The newspaper’s 5 June 2007 report described a workforce under pressure to meet the programme for LNG deliveries in the second half of 2008. It reported that Greer had referred to adverse comments and body language suggesting a team that lacked confidence. His prescription was not management-school subtlety: “Lead me, Follow me or Get out of my way.”
The Financial Times also reported that a Shell spokesman confirmed the email was genuine, while declining to discuss it further. That confirmation is important. This was not a forged document circulating in the fog around a contentious project; it was an authentic internal message from a senior project executive.
Patton Reaches Sakhalin
The memo acquired a life of its own because much of its language tracked a speech by US General George S. Patton to troops before D-Day. Greer replaced references to American soldiers with “pipeliners”, “engineers” and “professionals”, retaining the language of fighting, winning and contempt for cowardice.
Ed Crooks’s Financial Times follow-up, published on 7 June 2007, set the Patton passages beside the Sakhalin version. The point was not merely that a manager had borrowed a few stirring words. The juxtaposition exposed an extraordinary mismatch: a Second World War general addressing troops before combat, redeployed to rally engineers trying to complete pipelines in one of the world’s most difficult energy projects.
Lucy Kellaway returned to the subject on 11 June, using the memo in her workplace column. Her conclusion was memorable: the words were clear, whatever else could be said of them. She also observed that Greer’s acknowledgement of low morale was at least more direct than the usual corporate fog.
There were supporters. The Financial Times carried comments from people who regarded Greer as a forceful leader working in punishing conditions. Yet the message could not conceal the underlying problem: senior management was publicly exhorting staff to “bounce” from the bottom while the project faced delay, cost escalation and an increasingly difficult political environment.
Resignation And Shell’s Response
On 22 June 2007, the Financial Times reported that Greer had resigned from SEIC to pursue other business opportunities. Shell said the leaked email gave no grounds for an inquiry and paid tribute to his 27 years of service, including his SEIC secondment.
The point is not that an ill-judged motivational memo caused Sakhalin II’s problems. It plainly did not. The significance is that the episode gave an unusually candid glimpse of the internal atmosphere: an executive trying to impose battlefield language on a workforce dealing with enormous technical, scheduling and organisational pressure.
What Reached Parliament In 2008
In June 2008, WWF submitted evidence to the House of Commons Environmental Audit Committee during its inquiry into the Export Credits Guarantee Department and sustainable development. Its Sakhalin II background material contained a section headed “Corruption Allegations”. It said that allegations had been made by a whistleblower of inappropriate relationships between SEIC management and contractors, particularly Starstroi and its subcontractor SU4.
The committee’s published material linked that statement to a RoyalDutchShellPlc.com article, “The Sakhalin-2 whistleblower warnings which proved 100% correct”. This is a significant part of the documentary trail: the allegations were cited in a memorandum submitted to Parliament.
But the boundary must be kept firm. WWF’s submission reported allegations; it did not establish them as facts, and the publication of the evidence was not a House of Commons finding that the alleged conduct occurred. This article makes no such assertion.
WWF’s submission also raised wider environmental and social concerns about Sakhalin II, including the project’s proximity to the feeding grounds of the critically endangered western gray whale, the timing of an indigenous peoples plan and unresolved compensation claims. Those matters formed the context in which the whistleblower allegations were placed before the committee.
The Audit Controversy
By August 2008, the pressure around the project had widened into a dispute over its environmental review. The Observer reported that Freedom of Information disclosures showed Shell officials had sought to comment on, and in the view of campaigners influence, an AEA Technology lenders’ review of Sakhalin II.
Shell’s response, reported in the article, was that it was routine for Sakhalin Energy and its shareholders to comment on a draft report so as to ensure accuracy, and that the findings were AEA Technology’s alone. AEA likewise maintained that its report was independent and said it had accepted some suggestions and rejected others.
That dispute did not prove the separate whistleblower allegations in the WWF evidence. It did, however, show why independent scrutiny of Sakhalin II had become such a contested issue: Shell, campaigners, lenders, consultants and government bodies were arguing over not only the project’s impacts but also who controlled the account of those impacts.
Why The Memo Still Matters
The David Greer email is an authenticated document. The whistleblower claims later cited by WWF are allegations that must remain described as allegations. Keeping those two categories separate makes the story stronger, not weaker.
Together they show the two sides of Sakhalin II’s public paper trail. On one side, an acknowledged internal email revealed management’s combative response to project pressure. On the other, a parliamentary submission placed serious concerns from a whistleblower into the public record, alongside environmental and social criticism that had already made the project internationally controversial.
Sakhalin II did eventually deliver LNG. But the episode left a durable record of a project whose commercial, political and environmental difficulties were too large to be solved with borrowed lines from General Patton.
Sources
- Financial Times: “Pipeliners All!” Shell’s memo to Sakhalin, 5 June 2007. The contemporaneous cutting is reproduced in the supplied source file.
- Financial Times: Sakhalin motivational memo borrows heavily from Patton, 7 June 2007.
- House of Commons Environmental Audit Committee: WWF evidence, Annexe II, submitted 20 June 2008.
- The Observer: Shell comes under fire for role in Sakhalin audit, 31 August 2008.
- RoyalDutchShellGroup.com: The Sakhalin-2 whistleblower warnings which proved 100% correct, 6 January 2008.
*This website and sisters royaldutchshellgroup.com, shellnazihistory.com, royaldutchshell.website, johndonovan.website, shellnews.net, and shellwikipedia.com, are owned by John Donovan - more information here. There is also a Wikipedia segment, the Shell DPA Files, "Shell and the Spies", the Shell Leaks files, the Independent Shell Archive, as well as books written and published by John Donovan - Kindle eBooks. Timeline of the Donovan Shell Feud. Toxic History of Royal Dutch Shell Group. Shell and the Donovans: The Full Media Record — 550+ Articles, 110 Books, 40 Years. *All conjured up by internet wizz, Nick Gill.
























