Shell’s LNG Delusion: Betting Big on a Market That Doesn’t Want It

Nothing Screams “Strategy” Like Ignoring Reality

Ah, Shell—the ultimate sin stock, the champion of environmental destruction, and a firm favorite of investment giants like BlackRock and Vanguard—has once again graced the world with a vision of its glorious fossil-fueled future. This time, it’s an LNG pipe dream so detached from reality, you’d think they pulled it straight from an oil-stained magic eight ball.

According to Shell’s latest LNG outlook, the world is set to guzzle down up to 718 million metric tons of liquefied natural gas by 2040, a staggering 60% increase from today. Why? Because of Asia’s economic growth, the energy demands of AI, and the vague promise of “cutting emissions”—yes, you read that right, Shell is now selling fossil fuels as a climate solution. Comedy gold.

But there’s just one tiny, inconvenient problem: The numbers don’t add up.

More Gas, Less Sense

Shell’s forecast proudly announces a massive supply gap in the coming decades, with the company expecting global LNG production to hit 577 million metric tons by 2030—a whopping 141 million tons short of its own demand projections for 2040. In simple terms? Shell’s brilliant plan hinges on the industry magically finding a way to double production over ten years—despite the fact that current trends point in the opposite direction.

And even if LNG companies manage to scrape together the capital to fund this expansion, Shell faces another glaring contradiction:

1. LNG needs to stay cheap to compete with coal and renewables, especially in Asia, where countries like China, India, and Indonesia have every incentive to keep burning their own dirt-cheap coal rather than switching to expensive imported gas.

2. But investors want profit, meaning LNG prices need to be high enough to justify the colossal costs of expansion.

You see the problem, right? Shell can’t have it both ways.

Asia Isn’t Buying the Hype

Let’s talk about Shell’s beloved Asian market, where the company expects this gas-guzzling utopia to unfold. The reality? Asia is already showing signs of waning interest in LNG.

• China’s February LNG imports were the lowest in five years, barely scraping 4.47 million tons.

• Even December, a strong month, still lagged behind 2023 levels.

• China, the world’s biggest LNG buyer, has a habit of pulling back whenever prices rise—which is a problem when Shell is betting on a high-price, high-volume fantasy.

Meanwhile, China added 355 gigawatts of new wind and solar power in 2024 alone, further solidifying its commitment to renewables. Why bother with LNG when the sun and wind don’t come with energy dependence and market volatility?

Shell’s LNG Future: A Price-Demand Paradox

For Shell’s grand LNG vision to become reality, several fairy-tale conditions would need to happen simultaneously:

1. Asia would need to abandon its coal addiction overnight—despite the fact that China, India, and Indonesia produce over 6 billion tons of coal annually and have no plans to stop.

2. LNG companies would need to invest billions in expansion, all while bracing for lower prices.

3. Demand and prices would have to rise together—which, in case Shell missed it, is not how supply and demand works.

But hey, Shell’s never been one to let reality get in the way of a good investor pitch.

Maybe a Merger Will Fix It?

With Shell and BP both scrambling to double down on fossil fuels while shedding whatever “green” initiatives they once paraded around for PR points, perhaps the ultimate corporate monstrosity is on the horizon: a Shell-BP mega-merger.

Imagine the combined might of two oil-stained relics of a dying industry, pooling their resources to dig up and burn as much carbon as possible before the planet—and their stock value—collapses. If BlackRock and Vanguard want a true sin stock powerhouse, this might just be their chance.

But until then, Shell will keep peddling its LNG fantasy, hoping the world ignores the fact that the numbers don’t work, the market isn’t cooperating, and the planet is running out of patience.

This website and sisters royaldutchshellgroup.com, shellnazihistory.com, royaldutchshell.website, johndonovan.website, shellnews.net, and shellwikipedia.com, are owned by John Donovan - more information here. There is also a Wikipedia segment.