THE SHELL LEAKS FILES — 22 NOVEMBER 2026

THE SHELL LEAKS FILES — 22 NOVEMBER 2026

Archive reference: SLF-2007-126

The Sakhalin Papers CXVI: The Gray Whale Evidence — An Independent Investigation into Shell, 639 Scientific Recommendations and the Uncertain Future of Sakhalin’s Whales

Shell’s Sakhalin II development became the subject of an extraordinary 17-year programme of international scientific scrutiny. An independent panel examined underwater noise, offshore pipelines, seismic surveys, shipping and threats to an endangered gray whale population. Its recommendations helped persuade Sakhalin Energy to move a pipeline away from critical feeding grounds. But the scientists also publicly challenged the company’s decisions and criticised inadequate cooperation. Now, the panel’s original closing statement, authenticated Shell reports, International Whaling Commission records and Sakhalin Energy’s 2024 environmental disclosures reveal both genuine conservation achievements and important questions about the whales’ continuing protection.

AN INDEPENDENT DOCUMENTARY INVESTIGATION

By the Donovan–Shell Archive

Researched and drafted with assistance from ChatGPT. Based on original Shell corporate reporting, contemporaneous IUCN statements, records of the Western Gray Whale Advisory Panel, International Whaling Commission assessments, published scientific research and Sakhalin Energy’s environmental disclosures. Corporate statements, scientific findings and editorial conclusions are distinguished throughout.

Publication date: 22 November 2026

Collection: The Sakhalin Papers — Shell, Gazprom and Russia

Previous instalment: SLF-2007-125 — Three Offshore Platforms, One Environmental Directive

INTRODUCTION: THE 397 WHALES THAT WERE NOT A POPULATION COUNT

In 2024, Sakhalin Energy published an apparently encouraging figure concerning the gray whales feeding off northeastern Sakhalin Island.

Its photographic identification catalogue had reached 397 individual animals.

The total had increased from 352 in 2021, to 363 in 2022, to 375 in 2023.

During the 2024 field season, researchers had provisionally identified 190 individual whales, including 22 newly recorded animals.

Of those new identifications, 15 were calves and seven were adults.

The figures appear in the company’s original Non-Financial ESG Report 2024, on printed page 116.

The operator interpreted its longer-term monitoring evidence as indicating favourable conditions for the whales feeding near its offshore production facilities.

It also reported an estimated annual growth rate of 4.3–5.4% for the subpopulation.

These are significant disclosures.

But there is a fundamental distinction that should determine how they are interpreted.

A catalogue containing photographs of 397 different whales accumulated over many years does not establish that 397 whales were alive in 2024.

A photographic catalogue records individual animals identified during successive research seasons.

It may include whales that subsequently died.

It can grow because additional animals are photographed for the first time.

Its increase is not interchangeable with a scientifically estimated increase in the living population.

The distinction becomes particularly important when examining another original document.

In 2022, three senior scientists associated with the Western Gray Whale Advisory Panel published a closing assessment of the panel’s work.

They reported that the number of whales feeding off Sakhalin and southeastern Kamchatka had increased over the period from 1995 to 2020.

Their estimate for 2020 was approximately 220–270 individuals, excluding first-year calves.

But the scientists also identified unfinished conservation work.

They called for continuing population modelling, underwater-noise monitoring, additional research into whale movements, and better access to scientific data.

Their findings were neither a blanket condemnation of the oil industry nor an unconditional endorsement of its environmental performance.

They described measurable successes.

They also described shortcomings.

The contrast with Sakhalin Energy’s 2024 report is instructive.

The operator’s document describes continuing conservation programmes.

The independent scientists’ historical assessment explains why those programmes need rigorous evaluation.

And the International Whaling Commission has subsequently expressed concern about declining whale numbers using Sakhalin’s nearshore feeding area.

Those three strands form the basis of this investigation.

The central question is not whether Shell’s Sakhalin project contributed to whale research. It clearly did. The more important question is what that research establishes about the whales’ survival, the effectiveness of protective measures and the conservation work still required.

PART ONE: A POPULATION BROUGHT CLOSE TO EXTINCTION

1. The historical background

Gray whales once migrated through extensive areas of the western North Pacific.

Commercial whaling devastated their numbers.

The population associated with waters off Russia, Korea, Japan and China was driven to extremely low levels.

By the late twentieth century, its survival had become a major international conservation concern.

Researchers eventually documented surviving gray whales using feeding grounds off northeastern Sakhalin Island.

Those waters were also becoming an important centre for offshore oil and gas development.

The coincidence created an obvious conservation problem.

A small population of large marine mammals depended upon feeding areas where industrial activity was expanding.

Potential disturbances included underwater noise from seismic surveys, vessel movements, offshore construction, the installation of pipelines and the possibility of oil spills.

The risks were especially important because females needed sufficient food to support reproduction and successful calf rearing.

In February 2005, an Independent Scientific Review Panel convened under the auspices of the International Union for Conservation of Nature published its assessment of the potential impacts of Sakhalin II’s second development phase.

At the time, the population was estimated at approximately 100 animals.

The panel’s work formed part of a developing international effort to assess whether the project could proceed while protecting the whales.

Primary source: IUCN — Impacts of Sakhalin II Phase 2 on Western North Pacific Gray Whales and Related Biodiversity, Independent Scientific Review Panel, 2005.

IUCN

 

2. An important change in conservation status

There is a historical qualification concerning the whales’ conservation classification.

The western gray whale subpopulation was assessed as Critically Endangered on the IUCN Red List in 2000 and again in 2008.

Following evidence of population growth, it was reclassified as Endangered in 2018.

The IUCN Cetacean Specialist Group’s archive confirms that change.

This matters because historical descriptions of the whales as Critically Endangered should not automatically be repeated as statements of their subsequent status.

The revised classification represented genuine evidence of improvement.

But Endangered remains a serious conservation category.

The population is still small, and its long-term security depends upon successful reproduction, survival and protection across its migratory range.

The specialist group’s historical review recorded an estimate of only 51–72 reproductively active females in 2016.

That is a reminder of the population’s continuing vulnerability.

Scientific institutional source: IUCN Cetacean Specialist Group — Western Gray Whale Advisory Panel Archive, updated September 2024.

SSC Cetacean Specialist Group

 

PART TWO: WHAT SHELL ACTUALLY SAID IN 2005

3. An authenticated corporate record

One of the most important documents in the investigation is Shell’s original Sustainability Report 2005.

It remains available from Shell’s own corporate reporting archive.

The report contains a section concerning Sakhalin II and the protection of western gray whales.

At that time, Shell held a 55% interest in Sakhalin Energy.

Mitsui held 25% and Mitsubishi held 20%.

Shell therefore occupied the central shareholder position during the development’s environmental controversy.

The company’s report acknowledged that the whales’ summer feeding grounds were close to the project.

It also described the difficulties involved in developing major offshore infrastructure in that environment.

Shell stated that Sakhalin Energy had initiated an independent scientific review by experts convened through IUCN.

The company further reported that the review had resulted in an important change to its offshore pipeline plans.

According to Shell’s own 2005 account, Sakhalin Energy moved the offshore pipeline route approximately 20 kilometres farther from the whales’ feeding grounds.

This was a substantial engineering decision.

It demonstrated that independent environmental scrutiny could influence the design of a major industrial project.

The original corporate report also described acoustic modelling during platform construction, independent observation of underwater-noise levels, vessel speed restrictions and designated shipping routes.

Shell presented these measures as evidence of its commitment to reducing the project’s environmental impacts.

The company claimed that installation of the platform bases had been completed without observed disturbance to the whales.

That was Shell’s reported conclusion for the operations concerned, not proof that all subsequent industrial activity was harmless.

Nevertheless, the pipeline rerouting was a concrete conservation measure.

It was not merely a promise to conduct further research.

Authenticated Shell source: The Shell Sustainability Report 2005, printed page 24, Western Gray Whales (PDF).

Shell

 

PART THREE: THE INDEPENDENT SCIENTISTS CONFIRMED A REAL ACHIEVEMENT

4. The panel’s final assessment

The significance of the pipeline decision was independently acknowledged many years later.

The Western Gray Whale Advisory Panel’s closing statement, finalised in February 2022 and subsequently preserved by the IUCN Cetacean Specialist Group, was authored by Randall Reeves, Greg Donovan and David Weller.

The three scientists reviewed the history of the programme.

They identified Sakhalin Energy’s decision to reroute its offshore pipeline as perhaps the panel’s most tangible achievement.

That is especially important evidence.

The acknowledgement came from scientists involved in the independent review process, not from Shell’s public-relations department.

The panel also credited Sakhalin Energy with incorporating scientific recommendations into operational standards and practices.

These included measures intended to reduce noise disturbance, manage vessel movements, improve environmental monitoring and strengthen oil-spill response arrangements.

The scientists observed that some resulting practices exceeded the formal requirements of Russian regulation.

This is favourable historical evidence concerning Sakhalin Energy.

It should be included in any serious assessment of Shell’s environmental legacy.

The practical lesson is that scientific recommendations can result in measurable changes to industrial operations when companies accept them.

But the closing statement did not present the entire programme as an unqualified success.

It also described substantial difficulties.

Those difficulties are equally important.

Primary independent source: Western Gray Whale Advisory Panel — Closing Statement, Reeves, Donovan and Weller, 2022, preserved in the Cetacean Specialist Group archive (PDF).

iucn-csg.org

 

PART FOUR: THE 639 RECOMMENDATIONS

5. An extraordinary scientific record

The IUCN-convened whale-review programme began in 2004.

The continuing Western Gray Whale Advisory Panel was formally established in October 2006.

Its first meeting took place in November that year.

The programme continued until March 2022, when the contractual arrangement between IUCN and Sakhalin Energy expired.

During that period, the independent panels held 22 formal meetings.

They also convened 38 technical task-force meetings addressing specialised subjects.

The closing statement records that the panels and their predecessors issued 639 recommendations between 2004 and 2021.

Most were directed towards Sakhalin Energy.

Others concerned regulatory authorities and wider industry cooperation.

The recommendations covered matters ranging from underwater sound and vessel movements to seismic-survey procedures, population monitoring and oil-spill preparedness.

It is important not to mistake 639 recommendations for 639 proven violations.

Scientific recommendations can identify risks, propose improvements, request additional research or address deficiencies in existing arrangements.

Their number demonstrates the scope of the scientific programme.

It does not, by itself, establish the number of occasions on which Sakhalin Energy breached a law or permit.

Nevertheless, the recommendations represent an extensive contemporaneous record.

They provide a basis for examining what scientists advised, what the company accepted, what it disputed and how its practices changed over time.

For a documentary history of Sakhalin II, that record is particularly valuable.

PART FIVE: JULY 2007 — THE SCIENTISTS PUBLICLY CHALLENGED SAKHALIN ENERGY

6. The dispute over underwater noise

The historical record contains clear evidence that the relationship between Sakhalin Energy and its scientific advisers was not always harmonious.

On 20 July 2007, IUCN published a statement expressing serious concern about the company’s approach to managing underwater noise.

The Western Gray Whale Advisory Panel had recommended criteria intended to limit noise associated with offshore construction.

Those criteria included measures addressing prolonged exposure to lower noise levels.

Sakhalin Energy responded that implementation of the proposed criteria was not technically feasible.

It referred to procedures used during the preceding construction season.

The panel rejected the adequacy of that explanation.

Its concern centred upon the possibility that prolonged exposure to industrial noise could interfere with whales attempting to feed.

The scientists considered that pregnant females and females accompanied by calves might be particularly vulnerable.

This was not an allegation that a specific whale had been killed.

Nor was it a judicial determination that Sakhalin Energy had breached an enforceable noise limit.

It was an explicit scientific disagreement about whether the company’s proposed mitigation measures were sufficiently protective.

That distinction matters.

A company can comply with existing permits while independent experts argue that stronger safeguards are scientifically justified.

The question then becomes whether management has adequately considered the evidence and the foreseeable risks.

IUCN’s July 2007 statement establishes that Sakhalin Energy resisted particular recommendations concerning prolonged noise exposure and that the independent panel regarded its position as potentially unsafe for the whale population.

That is a substantial historical finding.

Contemporaneous source: IUCN — World Conservation Union Panel Voices Concern over Impact of Noise on Whales, 20 July 2007.

IUCN

 

PART SIX: FEBRUARY 2009 — ANOTHER DISAGREEMENT

7. The importance of timely scientific information

On 12 February 2009, IUCN published another statement concerning the relationship between Sakhalin Energy and the advisory panel.

The issue was the provision of scientific and technical information.

According to IUCN, the company had failed to supply relevant documents sufficiently far in advance of the panel’s fifth meeting.

The scientists argued that delayed access to information impaired their ability to evaluate operational risks and provide useful recommendations.

The statement is revealing because it did not describe an entirely failed relationship.

IUCN acknowledged that the panel and Sakhalin Energy had developed a working arrangement involving regular meetings and substantial exchanges of information.

But the scientists considered that the quality of their advice depended upon timely disclosure of relevant material.

Independent scientific review is most effective when researchers can influence decisions before operations take place.

It is less effective when information arrives too late for recommendations to be incorporated into planning.

The 2009 dispute therefore raises a question of scientific governance.

Was the advisory process merely reviewing decisions already made?

Or could it genuinely influence the company’s future operational choices?

The contemporaneous evidence establishes a dispute about the timeliness of information.

It does not establish deliberate concealment or fraud.

Contemporaneous source: IUCN — Scientists Concerned about Sakhalin Energy’s Inadequate Collaboration on Whale Conservation, 12 February 2009.

IUCN

 

PART SEVEN: THE SCIENCE ALSO RECORDED PROGRESS

8. The 2015 seismic-survey programme

The evidence contains important examples of successful cooperation.

In the summer of 2015, Sakhalin Energy conducted a seismic survey near an important gray whale feeding area.

Seismic surveys use powerful underwater sound pulses to investigate geological structures.

Such operations can create risks for marine mammals, particularly where feeding, communication and movement may be affected.

The company worked with the Western Gray Whale Advisory Panel to develop monitoring and mitigation arrangements.

An independent observer, Grigory Tsidulko, was appointed through IUCN.

He spent approximately a month observing the programme.

His responsibilities included examining how monitoring teams implemented the agreed procedures.

In June 2016, IUCN reported that Tsidulko had concluded that the company’s mitigation efforts were broadly consistent with its monitoring and mitigation plan.

The observer also identified improvements that could inform future surveys.

IUCN noted that Sakhalin Energy was the only company conducting seismic surveys in the area in 2015 that accepted an independent observer within its monitoring arrangements.

That is an important favourable finding.

It demonstrates that independent oversight was not merely a theoretical aspiration.

An observer was given access to operational information and was able to assess compliance with the agreed plan.

But the conclusion requires precision.

Compliance with an agreed mitigation plan does not necessarily prove that no whale experienced disturbance or that the plan represented the strongest scientifically possible protection.

It establishes that the particular operation was assessed against its applicable plan and that the observer reached a broadly favourable conclusion.

Those findings deserve recognition without being exaggerated.

Independent source: IUCN — Independent Observer Report on Whale Protection During the 2015 Sakhalin Seismic Survey, 15 June 2016.

IUCN

 

PART EIGHT: THE POPULATION FIGURES REQUIRE CAREFUL INTERPRETATION

9. What the 2022 closing statement established

The independent panel’s closing statement reported that the number of whales feeding off Sakhalin and southeastern Kamchatka had increased at approximately 5% annually over the period 1995–2020.

Its estimate for 2020 was approximately 220–270 individuals, excluding first-year calves.

That was evidence of a substantial long-term improvement from the very small population recorded during the 1990s.

It was not evidence that all conservation threats had disappeared.

The estimate was generated from scientific population analysis.

It was not a running total of every individual ever photographed.

The distinction is critical when comparing it with the replacement operator’s 2024 catalogue of 397 registered whales.

The two figures relate to different measurements.

The 2020 estimate concerned the number of animals in an assessed population or feeding aggregation under the applicable methodology.

The 2024 figure was a cumulative photographic-identification total.

They should not be used to calculate a four-year population growth rate.

Nor should the difference between them be described as evidence of 127–177 additional surviving whales.

That would be scientifically invalid.

10. The International Whaling Commission’s accepted historical estimates

A further independent benchmark appears in the International Whaling Commission’s 2022 recommendation concerning accepted abundance estimates.

The Commission recorded an estimate of approximately 200 whales for the Western Feeding Group in 2015.

It separately recorded approximately 282 whales for the Sakhalin and Kamchatka Feeding Group in 2015.

These are different assessment categories.

Their figures should not be treated as contradictory estimates of precisely the same population.

Nor can either be directly compared with the 2024 cumulative photographic catalogue without reconciling the underlying datasets, boundaries and methods.

The important lesson is straightforward.

Population abundance, feeding-area attendance, annual photographic identification and cumulative catalogue size are related but distinct scientific measures.

A rigorous investigation must preserve those distinctions.

Scientific source: International Whaling Commission — Recommendation SC2234, Accepted Gray Whale Abundance Estimates, 2022.

IWC Recommendations

 

PART NINE: THE MOST IMPORTANT CONSERVATION WARNING

11. Fewer whales using the nearshore feeding area

A significant qualification emerges from the International Whaling Commission’s more recent work.

In its 2023 recommendation, the Scientific Committee expressed concern about a decline in the number of whales using the nearshore feeding area off Sakhalin.

It urged continuation of the long-running Russian Gray Whale Project.

The Committee also called for the industry-funded research programme to make its photographic catalogues and associated data available through the IWC.

In 2024, the Scientific Committee reiterated these recommendations.

This is significant because a long-term increase in the wider feeding aggregation does not necessarily mean that whale numbers are stable at every location.

Changes in the number of whales using a particular feeding ground may reflect changes in habitat, prey availability, survey effort or whale distribution.

They could also be associated with disturbance or other environmental pressures.

The available recommendation does not establish which factor or combination of factors caused the reported decline in nearshore attendance.

It would therefore be premature to attribute that change specifically to Sakhalin II.

But it would also be inappropriate to ignore the warning simply because Sakhalin Energy’s wider photographic catalogue continued to grow.

The independent scientific concern about nearshore feeding-area attendance is compatible with a growing cumulative identification catalogue. Both findings can be true.

For conservation purposes, the decline warrants investigation.

The physical condition of individual animals, availability of prey, reproductive performance and use of the feeding grounds are particularly important indicators.

Primary source: International Whaling Commission — Recommendation SC2445, 2024, concerning western gray whales and continuing monitoring.

IWC Recommendations

 

PART TEN: THE OTHER THREATS TO THE WHALES

12. Fishing gear and accidental deaths

Offshore oil and gas development is not the only danger faced by gray whales.

Entanglement in fishing gear is a serious and potentially fatal threat.

In 2005, three female gray whales were reported to have died after becoming trapped in fishing nets in Japanese waters.

The independent panel discussed those deaths in its first meeting report.

The deaths illustrated how vulnerable a small population can be to additional mortality, especially when reproductively active females are involved.

The panel warned that continued mortality at that level could threaten recovery.

More than a decade later, the danger remained.

On 11 October 2018, IUCN reported research identifying a very high risk of entanglement in salmon nets near Sakhalin Island.

The research highlighted the overlap between fishing activity and the whales’ feeding habitat.

This is important when considering responsibility.

A whale injured in fishing gear cannot automatically be treated as a casualty of oil and gas development.

Equally, the existence of fishing-related mortality does not eliminate the need to examine industrial disturbance.

Conservation requires assessment of multiple threats.

Sources: WGWAP First Meeting Report, November 2006 (PDF) and IUCN — Western Gray Whales at Great Risk from Salmon Nets, 11 October 2018.

iucn-csg.org+1

 

13. The whales’ movements are more complicated than originally believed

Another major scientific development concerned migration.

For many years, researchers regarded the western and eastern North Pacific gray whale populations as largely separate.

Subsequent satellite-tracking, photographic identification and genetic evidence demonstrated that some whales feeding off Sakhalin travel across the Pacific to wintering grounds near Mexico.

Other individuals are associated with movements along Asian coastal waters.

This has made the population’s structure more complicated than the original assumptions suggested.

The Western Gray Whale Advisory Panel’s 2022 closing statement acknowledged these findings.

The International Whaling Commission also recognises the importance of understanding movements between the western and eastern Pacific.

This matters because conservation cannot be restricted to Sakhalin’s offshore platforms.

The same whales may encounter fishing gear, shipping, habitat changes and other threats during migration.

Protecting a feeding ground is necessary.

It may not be sufficient.

Institutional source: International Whaling Commission — Western Gray Whale Conservation Management Plan.

iwc.int

 

PART ELEVEN: THE ADVISORY PANEL’S CLOSURE

14. March 2022 — the end of a 17-year arrangement

The Western Gray Whale Advisory Panel ended in March 2022.

Its contract with Sakhalin Energy expired during the period of disruption associated with Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.

The independent scientists had held their final formal meeting in November 2021.

The corresponding report was finalised in January 2022 but was not officially released publicly.

The separate closing statement was finalised in February 2022.

The disappearance of the panel’s wider documentary record from IUCN’s website subsequently became another preservation issue.

In September 2024, the IUCN Cetacean Specialist Group announced that more than 80 relevant reports and documents had been recovered and made publicly accessible through its online archive.

The recovered material included panel reports, technical task-force documents and associated scientific records.

This is a substantial development for historical researchers.

It means that important primary-source material concerning Shell’s Sakhalin environmental history can once again be consulted.

But it also reveals the vulnerability of scientific documentation when long-running institutional arrangements end.

The Cetacean Specialist Group’s archival account confirms that the panel was discontinued and that its historical materials were removed from IUCN’s principal website following the invasion.

It does not establish that Shell ordered their removal.

Nor does it establish that IUCN intended to conceal the scientific findings.

The cause and administrative circumstances of the withdrawal should not be inferred without additional evidence.

The documented fact is that the scientific record became less accessible and was subsequently recovered in substantial part.

Source: IUCN Cetacean Specialist Group — New Content Available in the CSG Online Library, 18 September 2024.

SSC Cetacean Specialist Group

 

PART TWELVE: WHAT THE CLOSING STATEMENT REVEALED ABOUT INDEPENDENCE

15. Scientific independence was a continuing challenge

The panel’s closing statement deserves particular attention because it was written by scientists who had participated directly in the review process.

They acknowledged valuable cooperation with Sakhalin Energy.

They credited the company with implementing significant protective measures.

But they also described difficulties involving wider industrial cooperation and the sharing of scientific information.

One recurring problem concerned the relationship between company-funded research and independently managed data.

The scientists argued that conservation assessments would benefit from the integration of photographic identification and genetic information held by different research programmes.

The closing statement specifically criticised the failure to achieve full cooperation over a shared database involving the joint monitoring programme of Exxon Neftegas and Sakhalin Energy and the independent Russian Gray Whale Project.

According to the authors, the lack of a fully integrated and accessible dataset limited the potential scientific value of the collected material.

This was not a criticism of data collection itself.

It was a criticism of incomplete coordination and access.

The distinction is important.

Scientific monitoring can produce extensive information while still leaving important questions unresolved if different datasets are not readily comparable.

The panel also emphasised the need for continued independent oversight, transparent decision-making and secure preservation of research records.

It called for conservation obligations to apply consistently across different companies and industrial activities.

The underlying principle was that protection of the whales should not depend entirely upon the willingness of one operator to participate in voluntary arrangements.

That remains a relevant concern.

EDITORIAL ANALYSIS

16. Shell’s environmental record contains both achievement and disagreement

The documentary evidence does not support a simplistic account in which Shell ignored all scientific advice.

The original 2005 sustainability report records an important pipeline rerouting.

The independent panel subsequently confirmed that this was a major conservation achievement.

The company also adopted monitoring arrangements, vessel restrictions and other protective measures.

In 2015, Sakhalin Energy accepted independent observation of its seismic-survey mitigation programme.

The observer reached a broadly favourable conclusion concerning compliance with the agreed plan.

Those are substantial facts.

But the same historical record contains disagreements over underwater noise, the timeliness of scientific information and the adequacy of cooperation.

The scientists were sufficiently concerned to criticise the operator publicly in 2007 and 2009.

The subsequent closing statement continued to identify unresolved issues concerning data access and regional coordination.

The fair conclusion is therefore neither complete exoneration nor comprehensive condemnation.

Independent scientific oversight influenced Sakhalin Energy’s conduct and produced identifiable conservation measures. It also revealed differences between the company’s operational priorities and the protection standards advocated by its scientific advisers.

That is a more useful historical finding than either an accusation unsupported by evidence or a corporate account that treats monitoring expenditure as proof of environmental success.

17. The independent scientists’ greatest achievement may have been preserving uncertainty

Scientific research rarely provides absolute answers concerning complex ecosystems.

A whale population may grow during a period of industrial activity without proving that the activity was harmless.

A feeding area may experience declining attendance without proving that an offshore platform caused the decline.

An independent observer may confirm compliance with a mitigation plan without establishing that the plan eliminated every possible disturbance.

These limitations are not weaknesses to be concealed.

They are part of responsible scientific interpretation.

The panel’s own historical analysis provides an example.

Its first meeting report cautioned that apparent population improvement could reflect earlier reproductive success and should not be used to conclude that recent industrial activities had caused no adverse effects.

That distinction remains important when examining the 2024 monitoring figures.

Scientific conclusions should reflect the time periods, populations, measurements and uncertainties actually examined.

18. The 2024 operator report raises an important question about transparency

Sakhalin Energy’s continued collection of photographic identification data is valuable.

Its 2024 report indicates that substantial monitoring activity continued after the original operator was replaced in 2022.

That is encouraging.

But the report alone does not provide an independently reproducible population analysis.

It does not allow an outside researcher to reconstruct every individual identification, detection history, survival estimate or population-model assumption.

The International Whaling Commission’s recommendation for wider sharing of photographic catalogues is therefore relevant.

A catalogue may serve two different functions.

It can support the operator’s internal environmental programme.

And, if appropriately documented and shared, it can contribute to independent scientific assessment.

The latter requires common identification standards, secure archival arrangements and agreement on scientific access.

These are matters of conservation governance rather than simply corporate transparency.

For a small endangered population, long-term continuity of the scientific record is especially important.

19. What remains necessary for the whales’ protection

The strongest scientific recommendations emerging from the available documents concern continuity of monitoring and the assessment of cumulative threats.

Future evaluations need reliable estimates of abundance and survival.

They also require information about the number of breeding females, calf production, individual body condition and the use of feeding areas.

Underwater-noise studies remain relevant where seismic surveys, offshore construction or other intensive operations are proposed.

The effects of vessel traffic, fishing gear and possible changes in prey availability must also be examined.

The panel’s closing statement stressed that responsibility should not rest upon a single company or research institution.

Conservation requires cooperation among operators, scientists, government authorities and countries along the whales’ migratory range.

That conclusion is strongly supported by the historical record.

DOCUMENTARY FINDINGS

Established by original Shell documents

Shell’s 2005 sustainability report identifies the whale-conservation issue as a significant aspect of Sakhalin II’s development.

It confirms that Sakhalin Energy accepted advice to move offshore pipelines approximately 20 kilometres farther from the whales’ feeding grounds.

It describes acoustic modelling, independent observation, vessel speed restrictions and designated shipping routes.

These were company-reported mitigation measures, not findings that all environmental impacts had been eliminated.

Established by independent scientific and institutional records

The IUCN-convened independent scientific review began in 2004.

The Western Gray Whale Advisory Panel was established in 2006 and continued until March 2022.

The panels issued 639 recommendations between 2004 and 2021.

Their closing statement independently recognised the pipeline rerouting and other improvements as genuine achievements.

IUCN’s July 2007 statement records a dispute concerning noise-management criteria.

Its February 2009 statement records concern about inadequate advance provision of information.

IUCN’s June 2016 report records broadly favourable independent observation of Sakhalin Energy’s 2015 seismic-survey mitigation programme.

The panel’s closing statement identifies continuing weaknesses in regional cooperation, data integration and the availability of scientific information.

The IUCN Cetacean Specialist Group confirms that the western gray whale subpopulation’s Red List classification improved from Critically Endangered to Endangered in 2018.

Established as operator-reported figures

Sakhalin Energy’s 2024 ESG report records a cumulative photographic identification catalogue of 397 gray whales.

It records 190 individual whales provisionally identified during the 2024 field season, including 22 new identifications.

Those new identifications comprised 15 calves and seven adults.

The operator described favourable long-term population trends and continuing marine mammal protection arrangements.

The cumulative catalogue is not a census of all whales alive in 2024.

Established by the International Whaling Commission

Historical abundance estimates identify a small population that experienced substantial long-term recovery.

The IWC has also expressed concern about declining whale attendance at Sakhalin’s nearshore feeding area.

Its Scientific Committee has called for continued research and better access to data held by industry-supported programmes.

The IWC’s 2024 recommendation does not establish that Sakhalin II caused the reported change in nearshore whale numbers.

Not established

The evidence examined does not establish that Shell caused a particular decline in the population.

It does not establish that Sakhalin II’s mitigation measures eliminated every risk to the whales.

It does not establish that 397 western gray whales were alive in 2024.

It does not establish that the increase in photographic catalogue registrations demonstrates population growth at the same rate.

It does not establish that the decline in nearshore feeding-area attendance was caused by a particular operator or industrial activity.

It does not establish that Shell ordered the removal of the advisory panel’s records from IUCN’s website.

No court judgment determining that Sakhalin II caused a quantified gray whale population loss has been independently authenticated for this investigation.

No allegation of deliberate scientific falsification, concealment or unlawful harm to whales is advanced.

CONCLUSION: THE WHALES ARE MORE IMPORTANT THAN THE ARGUMENT OVER SHELL

For many years, the environmental history of Sakhalin II has been dominated by competing accounts.

Environmental organisations warned that industrial development threatened a vulnerable population of whales.

Shell and Sakhalin Energy described extensive environmental programmes and measures intended to reduce those risks.

Independent scientists assessed the evidence.

Some of their recommendations were accepted.

Others were disputed.

That history deserves careful examination.

The authenticated records establish that Shell’s involvement produced both controversy and significant conservation measures.

The pipeline rerouting was an important achievement.

The development of independent scientific monitoring was another.

But the panel’s criticism of particular operational decisions demonstrates why independent scrutiny remained necessary.

The subsequent population evidence provides grounds for cautious encouragement.

The whales feeding near Sakhalin and southeastern Kamchatka experienced a substantial long-term increase from the very low numbers recorded during the 1990s.

The IUCN conservation classification improved in 2018.

That progress matters.

However, recovery does not mean that the population is secure.

The number of reproductively active females remains an important consideration.

Fishing-gear entanglement continues to present serious risks.

The whales’ migration routes expose them to hazards beyond Sakhalin.

And the International Whaling Commission has expressed concern about reduced whale attendance in the nearshore feeding area.

The operator’s 2024 photographic catalogue is therefore useful, but insufficient on its own to establish the current condition of the population.

The more important measures concern survival, reproduction, habitat use and the availability of reliable, independently accessible scientific data.

There is another lesson in the termination of the Western Gray Whale Advisory Panel.

For approximately 17 years, international specialists participated in an unusual programme linking an industrial operator with independent conservation science.

Their work produced hundreds of recommendations and substantial documentation.

That programme ended in 2022.

Much of its historical record subsequently had to be recovered and preserved.

This reinforces the importance of maintaining scientific records independently of changing corporate and political circumstances.

The conservation evidence should remain available even when shareholders, operators and governments change.

The principal documentary conclusion is that Sakhalin II’s independent scientific oversight produced demonstrable protective measures and contributed to an extensive research programme. Yet important questions remain concerning the effectiveness of particular safeguards, the interpretation and availability of monitoring data, and the whales’ future security.

That conclusion recognises the conservation work undertaken during Shell’s involvement.

It also recognises the continuing responsibilities of those managing the environment today.

Ultimately, the welfare of the whales matters more than whether the historical record is favourable or unfavourable to any individual corporation.

The objective of scientific investigation should be to understand what protects the animals and what threatens them.

The objective of this archive is to preserve the evidence accurately enough that future researchers can make those assessments.

The Sakhalin Papers have documented the financial and political history of one of the world’s largest oil and gas developments.

But the conservation evidence reminds us that industrial history has consequences beyond balance sheets and corporate ownership.

The whales were present before Sakhalin II.

They survived decades of commercial whaling and subsequent industrial expansion.

Their continued survival requires scientific vigilance, effective protection and international cooperation.

If the documentary work undertaken during Shell’s involvement can contribute to better protection of the remaining gray whales, it will have a value extending far beyond the history of Shell itself.

The Sakhalin Papers continue.

PRINCIPAL DOCUMENTARY SOURCES

1. Shell — The Shell Sustainability Report 2005. Original Shell corporate document, printed page 24, describing whale-protection arrangements, the offshore pipeline rerouting and independent scientific consultation. Original Shell report (PDF).

2. IUCN — Impacts of Sakhalin II Phase 2 on Western North Pacific Gray Whales and Related Biodiversity, 2005.Original Independent Scientific Review Panel assessment. IUCN publication record.

3. Western Gray Whale Advisory Panel — First Meeting Report, November 2006. Original scientific record of population assessments, reproductive concerns, mortality risks and the advisory programme’s early objectives. Original report (PDF).

4. IUCN — 20 July 2007. Contemporaneous statement concerning disagreement over underwater-noise management and the panel’s concerns regarding Sakhalin Energy’s decisions. Original statement.

5. IUCN — 12 February 2009. Contemporaneous statement concerning inadequate advance provision of information to the advisory panel. Original statement.

6. IUCN — 15 June 2016. Independent observer findings concerning the implementation of mitigation arrangements during the 2015 Sakhalin seismic survey. IUCN report.

7. IUCN — 11 October 2018. Scientific report concerning the risks of entanglement in salmon nets near Sakhalin. IUCN report.

8. Western Gray Whale Advisory Panel — Closing Statement, 2022. Original scientific account by Randall Reeves, Greg Donovan and David Weller reviewing the panel’s achievements, weaknesses and unfinished conservation work. Preserved in the Cetacean Specialist Group’s archive, with editorial amendments incorporated into the archived version. Closing statement (PDF).

9. International Whaling Commission — Recommendation SC2234, 2022. Original recommendation concerning accepted historical gray whale abundance estimates. IWC record.

10. International Whaling Commission — Recommendation SC2445, 2024. Original recommendation concerning continuing monitoring, nearshore feeding-area attendance and the sharing of scientific data. IWC record.

11. IUCN Cetacean Specialist Group — Western Gray Whale Advisory Panel Archive, September 2024. Recovered archive of original panel reports and technical documentation. Scientific document archive.

12. Sakhalin Energy — Non-Financial ESG Report 2024. Original replacement-operator report, printed pages 115–116, recording continuing gray whale monitoring and photographic identification data. Original report (PDF).

13. Donovan–Shell Archive — 21 November 2026. SLF-2007-125, examining environmental oversight of Sakhalin II’s offshore platforms after Shell’s departure. Previous instalment.

DOCUMENTARY DISCLAIMER

This investigation examines historical environmental decisions, independent scientific advice, conservation monitoring and reported population trends associated with gray whales feeding in the western North Pacific.

Shell’s 2005 sustainability report is treated as an authenticated corporate source.

Statements concerning the company’s commitments, monitoring activities and reported environmental performance are attributed accordingly.

The Independent Scientific Review Panel, Western Gray Whale Advisory Panel, International Union for Conservation of Nature and International Whaling Commission records are distinguished from corporate reporting.

The Western Gray Whale Advisory Panel’s closing statement has been examined in the version preserved by the IUCN Cetacean Specialist Group, which identifies editorial amendments incorporated into the archived document. The original statement was finalised in February 2022.

The report distinguishes historical population estimates, annual photographic identifications and cumulative photographic catalogue totals.

The figure of 397 registered whales in 2024 is not presented as an independently verified living population count.

Historical improvements in abundance and conservation classification are acknowledged.

They are not represented as evidence that all environmental risks have been eliminated.

The International Whaling Commission’s concern about reduced whale attendance in Sakhalin’s nearshore feeding area is accurately attributed.

No conclusion is advanced that a particular offshore installation or industrial activity caused that change.

The investigation does not establish that Shell deliberately harmed whales, concealed scientific information, falsified monitoring records or unlawfully disregarded a binding conservation obligation.

Disagreements between Sakhalin Energy and the independent advisory panel are identified as documented scientific and operational disagreements, not automatically as legal violations.

The 2022 termination of the advisory panel and the subsequent removal of historical records from IUCN’s principal website are reported according to the Cetacean Specialist Group’s account.

No allegation is made that Shell directed the removal of those records.

No authenticated court judgment establishing that Shell or Sakhalin Energy caused a quantified gray whale population decline has been identified for this investigation.

The absence of such a judgment is not represented as proof that no environmental impact occurred.

The relevant scientific questions must be assessed through the available data and appropriate research methods.

Editorial observations concerning the desirability of independent monitoring, scientific transparency and continuing conservation measures are distinguished from established documentary findings.

Shell plc, Sakhalin Energy LLC, Gazprom, the International Union for Conservation of Nature, the International Whaling Commission, members of the former Western Gray Whale Advisory Panel, independent researchers and other interested parties are invited to provide original documentation, scientific corrections and attributed comment for fair consideration.

The website’s general disclaimer also applies.

NEXT IN THE SHELL LEAKS FILES

SLF-2007-127 — THE SAKHALIN PAPERS CXVII

The 639 Whale-Protection Recommendations — An Independent Investigation into What Sakhalin Energy Accepted, Resisted and Left Unresolved

For 17 years, independent scientists examined the environmental risks associated with offshore oil and gas development near Sakhalin’s endangered gray whales.

They issued 639 recommendations.

Some produced tangible results.

Sakhalin Energy moved a pipeline away from an important feeding ground.

The company introduced noise-mitigation arrangements, vessel restrictions and scientific monitoring.

Independent observers examined particular operations.

But not every recommendation was accepted.

In 2007, the scientists publicly challenged the company’s resistance to proposed noise criteria.

In 2009, they criticised the timeliness of information supplied for scientific review.

The panel’s final assessment identified further weaknesses concerning regional cooperation and the integration of research data.

Then, in March 2022, the advisory programme ended.

Its historical documentary record subsequently became less accessible before much of it was recovered by the IUCN Cetacean Specialist Group.

The next investigation will examine those recovered scientific records more closely.

It will seek to identify the most important recommendations issued during Shell’s involvement, distinguish those adopted by the operator from those disputed or deferred, and examine how the panel recorded the company’s responses.

Particular attention will be given to underwater-noise limits, seismic surveys, oil-spill preparedness, access to independent research data and protection of feeding areas.

It will also distinguish the company’s actual measures from commitments that were proposed but not independently verified as completed.

No assumption will be made that every scientific recommendation was legally binding or that disagreement necessarily constituted misconduct.

The central documentary question will be:

Of the 639 recommendations made during the Sakhalin whale-protection programme, which produced demonstrable conservation improvements, which encountered opposition, and what unfinished scientific work remains important to the whales’ survival?

The investigation will use the original panel reports and contemporaneous company responses wherever available.

The objective will be to preserve an accurate historical record while identifying lessons that remain relevant to the protection of endangered marine mammals.

The Sakhalin Papers continue.

*This website and sisters royaldutchshellgroup.com, shellnazihistory.com, royaldutchshell.website, johndonovan.website, shellnews.net, and shellwikipedia.com, are owned by John Donovan - more information here. There is also a Wikipedia segment, the Shell DPA Files, "Shell and the Spies", the Shell Leaks files, the Independent Shell Archive, as well as books written and published by John Donovan - Kindle eBooks. Timeline of the Donovan Shell Feud. Toxic History of Royal Dutch Shell Group. Shell and the Donovans: The Full Media Record — 550+ Articles, 110 Books, 40 Years. *All conjured up by internet wizz, Nick Gill.

Comments are closed.